I own 5 of them, and of those 5, they're dead-on accurate. (It's actually the top 11, so I've got slightly less than half.) Time to go pick up the rest, I guess. I mean, once I'm done with the games I just bought.
#1, by the way, is Psychonauts. I've mentioned this before and I can't emphasize it enough. If you like things that are excellent, you should get Psychonauts. If you only like crap, well, I can't help you then.